3 comments

  • wglb 2 days ago
    Paper at https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0067270X.2026.2... from Azania: Archaeological Research in Africa
  • Oras 2 hours ago
    The writing style (in Arabic) feels like a message in a chat. It's a mix between dialect and official Arabic.
    • interstice 1 hour ago
      Like, modern and understandable? I ask because English from more than a few hundred years ago is basically gibberish so I’m curious about languages where that didn’t happen.
      • wongarsu 57 minutes ago
        Depending on the author 17th century English can also be very close to modern English. A couple phrases will be off and the spelling is different, but most of the difficulty is more the author using constructions that have fallen out of use or "showing off" with overly complicated sentences.

        For example here's an excerpt from 1688's "Oroonoko"

          I have often seen and convers'd with this great Man, and been a Witness to many of his mighty Actions; and do assure my Reader, the most Illustrious Courts cou'd not have produc'd a braver Man, both for Greatness of Courage and Mind, a Judgment more solid, a Wit more quick, and a Conversation more sweet and diverting. He knew almost as much as if he had read much: He had heard of, and admir'd the Romans; he had heard of the late Civil Wars in England, and the deplorable Death of our great Monarch; and wou'd discourse of it with all the Sense, and Abhorrence of the Injustice imaginable. He had an extream good and graceful Mien, and all the Civility of a well-bred great Man.
      • asabil 27 minutes ago
        Yes Arabic from 1000 years ago is very much understandable today[1].

        [1] https://fluentarabic.net/arabic-unchanged-1000-years/

      • dghf 54 minutes ago
        Is six hundred years ago more than a few? Chaucer is still more or less comprehensible. (Though Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, from roughly the same time, not so much.)
        • biofox 25 minutes ago
          The Middle English spelling and phonetic shifts are what make it so painful to read. The words themselves though are mostly comprehensible with a bit of effort.

          Go back another four hundred years to Old English and Beowulf and it becomes complete gobbledygook (to me at least).

          • usrnm 9 minutes ago
            I wonder what modern English would look like if the battle of Hastings went differently
  • nephihaha 2 hours ago
    That was interesting, notwithstanding the editorialising comments by Tomasz Barański.