Simon Winchester has died

(nytimes.com)

104 points | by benbreen 3 days ago

16 comments

  • msisk6 1 day ago
    Well, that sucks. He's one of my favorite authors. I recommend the audiobooks which he reads himself.

    I especially liked "The Perfectionists: How Precision Engineers Created the Modern World" and "Knowing What We Know: The Transmission of Knowledge From Ancient Wisdom to Modern Magic".

    But all of his works are great.

    • bita_nidir 1 day ago
      I came to mention that book, known in the UK as "Exactly: How Precision Engineers Created the Modern World" (same book, different title). Very good book.

      If you're interested in that subject (starts around 1750s with Wilkinson boring out a cannon, then goes to James Watt because he needs a steam engine for his foundry. He sees James is struggling with a good seal due to cylinder tolerances. He uses the boring technique on a blank casting and the first industrial steam engine is born).

      If you find this interesting, I don't recommend keeping the book on your bedside table because you won't want to go to sleep!

      • giancarlostoro 1 day ago
        I never read his work, and I've been looking through his wikipedia, but I noticed he did the same with other books, slightly or completely different titles, is this due to what he felt the audience in each region would be more receptive towards in terms of a title, or is there another reason?
        • bombcar 21 hours ago
          This is done by publishers all the time, perhaps the most famous being Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone in the UK becoming the Sorcerer's Stone in the USA.

          It's often done because of a perceived (or real) difference in phrasing that would go over differently on the other side of the pond.

          • FatalLogic 12 hours ago
            >This is done by publishers all the time

            Also, to emphasize that point, book titles can be changed even more in translation to other languages. There are many examples, and the weirdest are probably titles that are translated between languages like Japanese, Chinese and Korean to European languages.

            A simpler example is Huxley's "Brave New World" which became “The Best of (All) Worlds” in some French editions[0]. It's a literary allusion which is meaningful in that culture.

            [0] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Meilleur_des_mondes

            • QuesnayJr 7 hours ago
              Interesting. The allusion (to Dr. Pangloss in Candide) is not unknown in English.
        • 2b3a51 23 hours ago
          I suspect that the publisher may decide to vary the title for different markets. I have seen this with books by other authors.

          PS: The dictionary book was great. All of those slips!

    • srean 1 day ago
      All of his books are a fascinating read.

      Apologies for the zero content comment, but damn it, was looking forward to what he would write next.

    • seemaze 13 hours ago
      He narrated the audiobook of The Perfectionists as well, a marvelous listen.
    • runnr_az 17 hours ago
      Definitely one of the most profound books I've ever read. I come back to it on AudioBook from time to time because I love it so much. He narrates, so it's like being told a long and windy story from Gandolf or some other wizened master.

      ... but I salute his entire catalog! Literally everything he did is fascinating / easily digestible.

  • ilamont 1 day ago
    He wrote a fantastic biography of Joseph Needham, a chemist at Cambridge who learned Chinese in his 30s and subsequently created an exhaustively thorough history of scientific discovery in ancient China that was published as a gigantic set of encyclopedias. The research into Needham's wartime travels in China (relying on university and Foreign Office archives) was top notch.

    https://www.theguardian.com/books/2008/sep/28/biography3

  • jimbo456 1 day ago
    His book on small British holdings in the 90s, Outposts, was an amazing read. He was a gifted writer who could humanize without romantize.
  • moioci 1 day ago
    My introduction to his work was Kraktoa: the Day the World Exploded. A fascinating read.
  • themadturk 14 hours ago
    Oh, that's too bad! I read my first Winchester, The Perfectionists, just this year, and a couple of other beside. Enjoyable and educational, the epitome of this type of non-fiction.
  • ddrmaxgt37 21 hours ago
    Pacific (given I’m in California and visit Asia often) has been one of my favorites.

    Glad he was so prolific before passing away.

  • stevoski 22 hours ago
    One of the best travel stories I’ve ever read was by Simon Winchester: The Most Perfect Hotel in the World
  • notjes 1 day ago
  • janandonly 1 day ago
    I can also recommend the movie named after the American title of his Oxford English Dictionary book.
  • sjdh76 1 day ago
    The madman kicked ass. A broken person can do unbroken work.
  • bookofjoe 1 day ago
  • toomuchtodo 3 days ago
  • dangerboysteve 20 hours ago
    Well that sucks. "The Professor and the Madman" is one of my favorite books.
  • adolph 22 hours ago
    If you enjoyed Stewart Brand's Maintenance you probably would also enjoy Winchester's The Perfectionists. Below is Brand on Winchester [0].

      Winchester’s book really shows how precision helps to drive progress. For Watt, a tolerance of one-tenth of an inch made his steam engines efficient. In Ford’s day, engineers and manufacturers could be precise at the level of a millionth of an inch. Today, chip fabricators have gotten things down to five nanometres. And, as the saying goes, a nanometre is to a tennis ball as a tennis ball is to the whole earth.
    
    0. https://www.newyorker.com/books/book-currents/stewart-brand-...
  • ggm 3 days ago
    > Simon Winchester was born in London on Sept. 28, 1944. He was the only child of Bernard and Andrée Winchester (de Wael.) By some accounts, his father, a British soldier, was imprisoned in Nazi Germany at the time of his son’s birth. In interviews, Mr. Winchester has frequently suggested that, when he returned from captivity, his father was not enthusiastic about his young son and sent him to boarding school in England at around the age of 5.
  • dofm 1 day ago
    Or "The Surgeon of Crowthorne" if you don't want the dumbed-down-for-the-US-market title.

    An important book; one of several that perhaps exists in part because of the room in the market that was carved out by Dava Sobel's Longitude.

    • jhhh 16 hours ago
      What's in a book name? that which we call a title by any other name would read as well;
    • Insanity 1 day ago
      Different marketing for different cultures/regions is not about “dumbing down”.
      • Hugsbox 15 hours ago
        In some cases it is. See Philosopher's Stone -> Sorcerer's Stone
        • themadturk 14 hours ago
          That's not dumbing down; it's a difference in usage between one side of the Atlantic and the other. "Philosopher" doesn't have the same connotation in the US as it does in the UK, especially to children, the book's target audience.
          • Insanity 12 hours ago
            I was also thinking of the above example, I do think "Sorcerer" has a more childish ring to it than "Philosopher". But then again, we are talking about children's books so it's still just marketing towards a target audience.
      • dofm 1 day ago
        Maybe, maybe not, but this time was. (Not the only time either)