15 comments

  • c-fe 34 minutes ago
    Within my friend group, we also switched now to Matrix. One of us is hosting it on their server, and we also use ElementX as clients. We did this to try get away from lack of privacy on Whatsapp and Telegram. It was also fun to tinker around with a selfhosted solution.

    In particular I love that I can now share my live location with this friendgroup and be very confident that noone is harvesting this data. With whatsapp, I was always very uneasy allowing live location access.

    Apart from one friend having issues receiving notifications, overall, we are having a positive experiene on ElementX/Matrix. I like especially how clean and well designed the iOS App looks. It simple and it just works.

    • Hoodedcrow 8 minutes ago
      Same but with XMPP! Much easier to host (there is an order of magnitude difference in resource consumption). Although my client can't do live location, only manually sending the current point.
    • renehsz 5 minutes ago
      How did you convince them to switch?

      In my experience, most people just don't care enough

    • MattTheMagician 26 minutes ago
      Any specific reason why you didn't go with Signal to replace Whatsapp or did you just not consider it at all?
      • codedokode 17 minutes ago
        Signal requires disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization and agreeing to their terms.
        • greggsy 6 minutes ago
          Signal is a non profit with robust terms that forbid monetisation of data.

          The data you share is minimal anyway, and can’t be used to decrypt any messages.

          It’s not suitable for any industries that require any form of record keeping or auditing, the minimal tradeoffs are well worth it, given that you don’t have to stand up your own solution.

          • InsidiousWombat 2 minutes ago
            The phone thing is no go for communication system used mainly on PCs, it's a chore and annoyance.

            Plus lack of any org level management

        • WithinReason 6 minutes ago
          no it doesn't require disclosing a phone number to a commercial organization
  • mogoh 6 minutes ago
    I really really hope that matrix with fractured client landscape, session verification, encryption errors, half-baked spaces, usability problems and slow development (Element X when?) improves. I use it daily and the problems are real. EC switching to matrix might add some development forces and money.
  • jareklupinski 41 minutes ago
    > Live presence was switched off. As more users came on board, the load from live presence (the real-time “online/away” indicator) started to affect performance, so the team disabled it.

    im taken back to my AIM days; imagining someone setting up special alert sounds for when their favorite official comes online

    • eterm 33 minutes ago
      This seems surprising to me. I think live presence is an essential part of real time communication, but also something that should be well understood how to scale?
      • jareklupinski 24 minutes ago
        i could see how after 10k users, the logarithmically? growing time/resource pressure of checking more users against every list, without properly distributing the data / sharding, starts to creep in
        • eterm 1 minute ago
          Perhaps I'm not understanding the Matrix model, is there no central broker that is holding user contact relations and fanning out and directing statuses / messages?

          Because, otherwise, even if you went crazy and did the most naive implementation:

              Storing for every User
              User -> List <User Contacts>
          
          And the reverse: User -> List<Users who have you as contact>

          And even then if you go full quadratic and have literally everyone have everyone else as a contact, and store and update the online status for each pair, and do that for each direction, you still shouldn't have scaling issues at 50k users, as that just isn't that much data?

          By 500k Users you might be starting to feel it with a naive approach, but 50k? It shouldn't be a bottleneck unless status updates are causing cascade effects into other systems.

          And that's just an analysis of the most naive design I could think of!

      • techpression 18 minutes ago
        Indeed, this seems like a really low number for when to run into issues, unless they're running it on a shared VPS and/or it's just not very well built.
    • falcor84 36 minutes ago
      Didn't ICQ solve this at a much larger scale 30 years ago?
      • LegitShady 34 minutes ago
        It's not the same without the uhoh sound. It never really was.
  • seanieb 31 minutes ago
    This is a disaster. Matrix's encryption is a tire fire. They continually say they're going to fix it but it's still no where near the security and privacy needed for national security use-cases.

    Their work to move to MLS seems to be abandoned. https://arewemlsyet.com/

    I applaud the people working on Matrix, it worthy project, but I feel the E2EE issues are at a level close to negligence.

    • teekert 28 minutes ago
      I recently listened to a podcast addressing this (one of the hosts works on Matrix/Element), basically, the "Unable to decrypt message" is what almost any error ends in. Also, they recently tried to remove all these issues and managed a 10x reduction, another highly focused effort may reduce it another 10x. I believe this was on the Late Night Linux podcast [0].

      In any case, I use Matrix for anything FOSDEM related and I have seen 1 of these errors over the last year, said user said they replied from within an Android notification fwiw.

      I really enjoy Matrix/Element tbh.

      [0] https://latenightlinux.com/

      • seanieb 19 minutes ago
        > basically, the "Unable to decrypt message" is what almost any error ends in

        That's not the issue(s) I'm referring to. And typical of Matrix's lack of engagement with weaknesses and issues that have been raised several times. They continue to neglect the issues their protocol has.

        This podcast goes into some of the details: https://securitycryptographywhatever.com/2022/11/02/Matrix-w...

        However, I would be prepared for a "we fixed those issues" claim which really amounts to shallow fixes that move the issue elsewhere.

        The proposal to move to MLS was accepted for a lot of reasons, reasons that have not, or cannot be addressed with their current protocol.

    • JadedBlueEyes 20 minutes ago
      There's a lot of parallel work going on to improve encryption in Matrix, including MLS. That particular effort is paused, but there are various other efforts.

      You also have to remember that this is a million times better than the status quo: Teams. Cleartext directly to the US.

  • sixhobbits 43 minutes ago
    I really really want to like Matrix and I try it every few years and it just seems bad.

    I'd be willing to bet that they migrate to something else after 12 months.

    • vidarh 32 minutes ago
      I've found Matrix really nice for isolated setups, funnily enough.

      E.g. my wireguard network has an isolated/non-federated Matrix server all my AI agents to talk to me over. It's great for that, but I have no interest in using it to talk to people.

    • rcymerys 39 minutes ago
      Out of curiosity, what's so bad about it? I haven't used it myself, but it looks like (just) a chat app?
      • wtch98 37 minutes ago
        It's not about better, its about incentives. Someone will be incentivised to move to a paid platform as it will look better on their CV (I sucessfully implemented a major 15 million euro project), and Slack will of course help them with the finance case
        • Jtarii 35 minutes ago
          Could they not also say "I saved 15 million euros by moving to an open platform"
          • nsoam 1 minute ago
            It's the public sector. No one is incentivised to save any money. In fact, saving money may make someone think it's okay to reduce your budget, which is bad.
          • notabotiswear 24 minutes ago
            Someone who saves the government money by decoupling it from the private sector is probably not going find many friends in said sector after their tenure ends. Revolving doors, like any machine, needs greasin'...
    • raphinou 21 minutes ago
      I also want to like matrix and maybe even more xmpp, but my experience with those is until now suboptimal to say the least. Trying delta chat now....
    • jillesvangurp 17 minutes ago
      We tried it out for a few weeks earlier this year with a small team. It's alright but there are some annoying defaults (no link previews by default being one of the more annoying ones). You have to opt in to that on every channel for every user. I get why they did that but basically usability and UX is thrown under the bus here because of some hypothetical privacy issues.

      That's nice if you are genuinely paranoid on this front (rightfully or otherwise) but really sucks if you want people to share links with each other (one of the big use cases we seem to have for using tools like this).

      Related to that, a side effect of all the e2e encryption is that it's really hard to give people or agents access to the full history of a channel. It's not impossible but it involves jumping through some hoops. And of course a primary reason for us switching away from Slack was using AI agents in our chats more and experimenting with running some of our own bots and something that is sometimes referred to as a company brain.

      Instead of fighting the tool we switched the tool. We picked Zulip around the same time the founders of that project were hired by Anthropic. For the migration, I gave AI access to my matrix keys and it moved over most of our channels to Zulip. Since Zulip has topics, I also made it group messages by topic.

      I like Zulip so far. They could use a UX refresh in the client. It looks a bit dated and meh. But otherwise it does the job. With both Zulip and Matrix, I orchestrated the rollout and hosting with AI, including giving admin privileges to manage the whole thing. Works surprisingly well with both. But jobs like add this person to that channel and given them such and such rights are working flawlessly. We had some openclaw thing running for a while but we gave up on that (too much issues with that). But we have a lot of chatgpt scheduled automations and some scripts and skills that allow it to search through and post in Zulip channels. Very useful.

      If you don't want to self host, Zulip has a generous freemium tier as well in their managed hosting. Haven't tried it but looks like a decent starting point if you want to try it out. You can migrate to self hosted later, if you want.

      • GrinningFool 3 minutes ago
        > no link previews by default being one of the more annoying ones)

        It's not just about privacy. To me, this is more usable - it always annoys me, the default habit of taking up half a (phone) page with a giant site card. If it just resolved title (and used normal chat-sized font) it would probably be good, but nothing seems to do that.

    • apopapo 41 minutes ago
      Do you have a better alternative in mind?
      • randypewick 40 minutes ago
        xmpp?
        • pferde 20 minutes ago
          They said "better".
        • gspr 20 minutes ago
          I'm so sad XMPP never took off. I remember being annoyed by the fragmented state of support for pretty vital "extensions" though. Has anything changed in that regard? I remember there was talk of consolidating a bunch of must-have extensions, like E2EE, into a single highly recommended one – did that go anywhere?
  • tkel 1 hour ago
    Hopefully they add some dev resources and not just users
    • FinnKuhn 30 minutes ago
      As you can see this blog is from "Element", who are offering Matrix deployments for enterprise and governments as a service, so they are definitely being paid for their work. As the company was founded by the Matrix creators, I'm sure they are also spending dev resources on it, but you can read more on that here: https://element.io/en/matrix-relationship

      I personally think this is a good example of how you can build an open-source product and still profit of it commercially by offering it as a vendor to enterprise and governments.

  • testtestmetest 11 minutes ago
    Fun fact Matrix was made by employees of a company accused (probably accurately) of being a mossad front company.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdocs

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matrix_(protocol)#:~:text=The%...

    Edit (downvotes within literally 3 seconds lol)

  • 150g2 10 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • rwmj 1 hour ago
    Given how much time I spend "verifying my device" and other issues with simply making it work, and multiplying that by 40000, I feel very sorry for them.
    • codedokode 45 minutes ago
      Yes it is awful. I do not even understand how I can "verify" a temporary browser session which gets destroyed after a log out.

      Reminds me of WhatsApp vs Telegram. In Telegram to log in from a new device, you just enter the phone number and the code. In WhatsApp you need to scan some codes, do other things, overcomplicated.

      • danelski 2 minutes ago
        Telegram doesn't have the E2E encryption apart from the private chats bound to a single device. No wonder their process can be simpler.
    • polytely 53 minutes ago
      real problems like that at this scale will probably result in it being improved which seems like a good thing to me
    • harrouet 36 minutes ago
      It is painful but that's what makes it secure.
  • magahugu 37 minutes ago
    Long time enemy l element and matrix user here. Indeed the verification process of new sessions is complicated. Something they'll surely address as they grow (until no security advantage is left...)
  • kvgr 7 minutes ago
    I mean good. But given how much impacts Russia has on some EU countries, how many people it can bribe to do its bidding. I am waiting for some leak here.
  • dannysilo 30 minutes ago
    https://slashdot.org/story/26/10/02/1743247/eus-microsoft-te...

    > The European Commission's rollout of Element Pro as a self-hosted alternative to Microsoft Teams has received harsh criticism from officials, with users citing poor usability and calling the tool "absolute shit."

    It doesn't seems they're enjoying it

    • FinnKuhn 27 minutes ago
      I'm sure you will find more than enough users that would also describe Microsoft Teams as absolute shit, but it is also not intended to replace Teams, but offer an additional channel for more sensitive communication that you wouldn't want to have via Teams.
  • soco 1 hour ago
    Somehow it's not surprising that the readership here doesn't understand why would Europe want to pay the high price of riding itself of US dependencies, but somehow it's still surprising.
    • raffael_de 1 hour ago
      seems like the rollout was a net positive.
      • gostsamo 31 minutes ago
        still to be decided, this is an element publication and they have interest to spruce things up for the other potential clients.
    • gostsamo 32 minutes ago
      My impression is that element is secure, Europe needs secure, but it does not imply that we need element. There are other secure solutions, but also enterprise element might be different from the consumer version that so many people dislike.
  • usern20260720 44 minutes ago
    Europeans do not develop seem to be developing for the masses. The French were allegedly developing a google drive alternative, for French civil servants. If it was for our institutions, the AI would only be available for civil servants. We despise the American mass surveillance tools but we crave them and depend on them
    • kergonath 5 minutes ago
      > The French were allegedly developing a google drive alternative, for French civil servants.

      That seems a bit unfair. Most of the new tools developed for the civil service and government are open source and can be used by anyone [1]. The servers are not (it’s a combination of self-hosting and contracts with companies), but that’s the same anywhere and I don’t really see how it could be (or should be) different, considering the requirements.

      It’s better than the alternative, which is to do exactly the same thing with proprietary software from mostly American companies (which itself would not be too much of a problem if it were not for things like the CLOUD act).

      > If it was for our institutions, the AI would only be available for civil servants.

      I don’t see what makes you think that. They are already deploying internal AI tools (“they” being very broad, it’s true of both member states governments and EU institutions) and it is not incompatible with companies providing services to the general public. It’s the same in the US: random people in Louisiana cannot use the NSA’s infrastructure or access internal tools at the DoD or the DoE’s HPC clusters.

      [1] the Google Drive equivalent, for example, is here: https://github.com/suitenumerique/drive

    • greggsy 29 minutes ago
      There are dozens if not hundreds of Drive and office alternatives in all regions of the globe, designed to fill any number of niches, including data sovereignty.

      They’re not as big as Google, but many of them have much better support and features.

      You won’t see these players on the front page of HN but you’ll come across them if you work in or around government.

  • rdwrrr 1 hour ago
    [flagged]
    • nisegami 44 minutes ago
      Can't be worse than paying Microsoft for Teams.